I have neutral feelings about this cleanser.   I ran out of my Purity Made Simple and needed something.  I chose this type because of the weather change and my dry skin-I didn't want anything harsh.   I love the pump, it is very easy to use.   It doesn't lather up at all, but that doesn't bother me but I can see how some might not like it.   I suggest using a make up remover first.   My face does not feel dried out at all and it is extremely gentle.   The reason I said I wouldn't buy it again is because I want to try something else but it's not bad.